Baked to Order

Ready to place an order? Please fill out the form below, and we
will contact you within 1 business day with pricing and additional details :)

All from scratch, all the time!

Once you’ve tasted what homemade, preservative-free baking tastes like – you will expect nothing less.

Hi! I’m Aspen.

Born and raised in the Amish Country of Lancaster, Pennsylvania, baking has always played a large role in my life and in the relationships I have with my family. Shortly after relocating to Tampa, FL, I noticed the lack of Amish baked goods in the area. Almost simultaneously, I realized I no longer had a large group of family members to carry out my passion for baking. - And just like that, Aspen’s Bakery was born.

Aspen’s Bakery is rooted in traditional Amish-style baking. Located in Tampa, Florida, our baked goods are made from traditional, passed-down Amish recipes and have been perfected over generations. We’re known for our preservative-free, heartwarming treats such as whoopie pies, sweet breads, cookies, and cinnamon rolls. We also offer custom orders for when you need an extra hand in the kitchen!

We use real ingredients and bake everything fresh - the old-fashioned way - for those who want the best and settle for nothing less.